Targeting entire niche or targeting a niche via category

[UKcart]

There are two types of situation here.

1. The kw will be "Top Perfume", where all the sub-niches such as cars, home, offices will be targeted from a single page or article.
2. The kw will be "Top Perfume for car/offices/homes", where all the kw's will be targeted through separate pages.

From SEO point of view which will be more beneficial.

[frank]

The later one will perform better for sure.

If people comes straight forward looking specifically for home or offices then surely the second option will perform better than the first one.